Source: TC AIM 2.12.3.4 Tail Plane Stall
Description:
(2.12.3.4 Tail Plane Stall
As the rate at which ice accumulates on an airfoil is related to the shape of the airfoil, with thinner airfoils having a higher collection efficiency than thicker ones, ice may accumulate on the horizontal stabilizer at a higher rate than on the wings. A tail plane stall occurs when its critical angle of attack is exceeded. Because the horizontal stabilizer produces a downward force to
counter the nose-down tendency caused by the center of lift on the wing, stall of the tail plane will lead to a rapid pitch down. Application of flaps, which may reduce or increase downwash
on the tail plane depending on the configuration of the empennage (i.e. low set horizontal stabilizer, mid-set, or T-tail), can aggravate or initiate the stall. Therefore, pilots should be very cautious in
lowering flaps if tail plane icing is suspected. Abrupt nose-down pitching movements should also be avoided, since these increase
the tail plane angle of attack and may cause a contaminated tail plane to stall. A tail plane stall can occur at relatively high speeds, well above
the normal stall speeds. The pitch down may occur without warning and be uncontrollable. It is more likely to occur when the flaps are selected to the landing position, after a nose-down pitching maneuvers, during airspeed changes following flap extension, or during flight through wind gusts.
Symptoms of incipient tail plane stall may include:
(a) abnormal elevator control forces, pulsing, oscillation, or vibration.
(b) an abnormal nose-down trim change (may not be detected if autopilot engaged);
(c) any other abnormal or unusual pitch anomalies (possibly leading to pilot induced oscillations);
(d) reduction or loss of elevator effectiveness (may not be detected if the autopilot is engaged);
(e) sudden change in elevator force (control would move down if not restrained); and/or
(f) a sudden, un-commanded nose-down pitch.
From the Ground Up:
Because of the narrow camber of the airfoil section and the small radius of curvature of the leading edge, tailplanes are very susceptible to ice accretion. The tailplane has an ice collection efficiency that is twice or three times that of the wings. If there is a half inch of ice on the wing, the accumula- tion on the tailplane may be an inch or more. In certain cir- cumstances, ice may be accumulating on the tailplane when there is no visible ice on the wing.
The principal danger attributable to tailplane ice occurs during approach and landing when the flaps are extended or after nose-down pitch and speed adjustments are made following flap extension. Most tailplanes are set at an angle of incidence to provide negative lift to balance the lift of the wings. During approach and landing, the tail is already at a high angle of attack. Extension of the flaps causes a major change in the downwash on the tail and a further increase in the angle of attack of the tailplane. If, at the same time, there is substantial ice contamination of the tailplane, tailplane stall is likely to occur.